Saturday, November 21, 2026
HomeSoftware EngineeringSAFe Case Research: Transformation Notes From the Discipline

SAFe Case Research: Transformation Notes From the Discipline

[ad_1]

This text is an element three of Toptal’s Agile scaling sequence, designed to information venture managers of their workforce growth efforts. Make sure to learn half one, “5 Agile Scaling Frameworks In contrast: Which One Ought to You Use?” and half two, “Agile Scaling: SAFe Finest Practices for Scrum Masters.”

Agility is practiced in some vogue by 94% of corporations, based on the fifteenth Annual State of Agile Report. However analysis additionally means that 90% of organizations battle with enterprisewide Agile implementation. Usually, it’s the work of Agile coaches, Scrum masters, and different venture administration professionals to guide and arrange these efforts. Typically, they’re working with groups or departments which can be resistant to vary, in an organization tradition that’s obscure.

On this roundtable, three Toptal venture managers focus on the challenges of main Agile transformations. As a result of their options comport with the Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe), we additionally spoke with Dean Leffingwell, creator of SAFe. Their collective insights illustrate the necessity for SAFe practitioners to organize a transparent imaginative and prescient of what agility is and a management plan that may convey recalcitrant groups on board.

Speaking SAFe With the Framework’s Creator

SAFe, a framework formalized by Scaled Agile, dates again to solely 2014. However for Leffingwell, the work started when he first encountered Agile groups within the early 2000s. As a software program growth methodologist, he was impressed with the outcomes of Agile practices on dev groups, and he instantly started exploring how the mindset might be utilized throughout a complete firm. If an Agile workforce may produce outcomes, what may a workforce of aligned Agile groups produce? How may Agile practices be used for full-scale transformation tasks at nationwide or worldwide corporations? As Leffingwell places it, “I like software program growth. I like Agile. I simply need it large.”

A bar graph titled
SAFe is essentially the most extensively used scaled framework, favored by 37% of respondents within the fifteenth Annual State of Agile Report.

Within the years since, corporations have acknowledged the advantages of SAFe, together with shorter deliveries, larger product high quality, better effectivity, and extra engaged staff. As of 2021, greater than a 3rd of organizations world wide used SAFe, and amongst its most necessary elements are the shared processes and unified language that it offers. For instance, if one workforce thinks a dash is 2 weeks lengthy and one other thinks it’s 30 days, it creates what Leffingwell describes as a “Tower of Babel drawback.” It’s exhausting for groups to debate what options so as to add if they’ll’t even agree on what “function” means. “You [need] folks working in a standard method if you wish to construct large options,” he says. “There’s not a time period in our trade that isn’t overloaded, like ‘iteration’ or ‘dash’ or ‘backlog.’ That’s not useful in case you’re making an attempt to work throughout workforce and regional boundaries.”

Agile Success Tales

Getting everybody at an organization to undertake a unified method of talking about and doing work is a frightening job even when there’s an amazing urgency for change. In established firms, it may be more durable. Leffingwell elaborates: “You’re trying on the largest corporations on the earth which can be making plenty of cash and doing extremely properly and competing—and so they have to vary. Effectively, the query for them is why ought to they?” The Toptal venture managers featured right here every encountered questions like this throughout their very own scaling actions, and every discovered their very own method of working by means of their Agile transformations utilizing SAFe.

Demonstrating Worth

Alvaro Villena, a Toptal venture supervisor in Santiago, Chile, not too long ago accomplished a SAFe transition for a portfolio creating a cross-business platform. “The primary milestone in my transition was conducting a worth stream workshop,” he says. In easy phrases, a worth stream workshop is a kickoff assembly to establish the complete enterprise course of from idea to supply and all of the steps, customers, methods, and ache factors in between.

Getting representatives from the complete enterprise into the workshop helped Villena perceive the corporate tradition and what his obstacles can be. “Earlier than we carried out the workshop, there was a construction the place one enterprise had their workforce, one other enterprise had their workforce, and the following enterprise had their workforce—the three didn’t discuss to one another.”

Villena discovered that though all of the groups shared comparable ache factors, there was no collaboration on options. As an illustration, though each enterprise within the portfolio shipped merchandise, just one had developed a monitoring system. There was no purpose they couldn’t all use it, besides that no person had shared the information. As soon as the workshop bought them speaking, information began to move amongst groups, companies, and product homeowners. “That form of dialog was actually, actually highly effective for this system. It was a pleasant start line,” Villena says. When DevOps, design, and product all know what different groups are doing, they see that there are answers within the firm that they are often utilizing. “They begin asking, ‘How can I’ve that?’ And that’s the place you step in and say, ‘Comply with this course of.’”

“No one desires change till they know why. So that you begin with a why and provides them a greater future.”Dean Leffingwell, creator of SAFe

Leffingwell is aware of that groups are generally resistant. “No one desires change till they know why,” he tells Toptal. “So that you begin with a why and provides them a greater future.” Giving groups a glimpse of how far more environment friendly they are often is a robust instrument for change management.

Even when everyone seems to be enthusiastically on board, it’s best to nonetheless count on rocky begins. Groups which can be accustomed to conventional Waterfall growth and large releases, for instance, could have hassle transferring to a extra iterative and agile growth course of, even when they see the worth in it. “The primary program increment that we did was form of a catastrophe with the groups,” says Villena. “And we knew it will be; we instructed the consumer to count on that the primary three months could also be troublesome.” To compensate for this, he in-built a one-time weeklong iteration on the finish of the primary program increment (PI) wherein the groups may consider their progress. He organized a dash devoted solely to course of enhancements and evaluations that will transcend the same old examine and adapt. He discovered it helpful to use an Agile mindset to not simply the product but additionally the enterprise transition, taking the time to step again, see what labored and what didn’t, and alter accordingly.

Creating Small Victories

It’s necessary to be ready for sudden obstacles in your SAFe adoption. Some years in the past, Toptal venture supervisor Miroslav Anicin in Belgrade, Serbia, was transitioning a telecommunications firm to SAFe. The corporate had outsourced all of its software program growth. Incorporating an off-site workforce wasn’t a very onerous job—the problems concerned have been primarily logistical. However the effort created unexpected challenges in transitioning the corporate itself. “I used to be trying to find the competencies we want within the launch prepare,” he says. “And all the folks I had to select from have been from advertising and marketing, from authorized, from merchandise, from finance—utterly missing the Agile mindset and even any expertise in Agile.”

It grew to become evident that administration had no expertise dealing with Agile groups. Distributed decision-making requires managers to relinquish some management, a reality management can balk at in the event that they’re not skilled with Agile frameworks. To resolve for this, Anicin needed to prepare from the underside up and from the highest down, teaching leaders together with their groups.

Such a transfer to extra decentralized decision-making requires “altering the way in which of working from command and management, by means of servant-leadership, to this empowering tradition of studying and tradition of Agile—and the power to tolerate errors,” says Leffingwell.

Anicin started the method of scaling incrementally—with small Agile tasks carried out inside single groups, not inside a SAFe framework—so particular person groups may develop some hands-on expertise. These tasks needed to be nonessential and sufficiently small that the corporate wouldn’t be harmed if one thing went flawed on the primary strive however helpful sufficient to point out the workforce what might be completed with the method. As an illustration, the advertising and marketing workforce created an inner advertising and marketing marketing campaign, throughout which Anicin taught them the fundamentals of Scrum. Much like Villena’s workshop, these smaller tasks display the worth of Agile in actual phrases, so workforce members and management can see the advantages of brief releases and steady enchancment earlier than the full-scale transition.

Assembly the Wants of Your Groups

When Imane Marouane, a Toptal venture supervisor based mostly in Paris, led a metamorphosis for a big, multinational monetary establishment, she stepped right into a chaotic surroundings the place particular person groups produced strong work however shared no companywide imaginative and prescient. “Every workforce had their very own precedence. Every product supervisor wished their product to be delivered first.”

SAFe’s resolution to this drawback will be discovered within the weighted shortest job first (WSJF) mannequin. WSJF offers a regular for prioritizing work so when it’s time to determine what the following job ought to be, step one doesn’t contain disputes over find out how to rank significance. In a flow-based Agile system, you don’t have to fret about delivering every little thing without delay as a result of, as Leffingwell says, “crucial factor is what job to do subsequent. And that’s a a lot simpler query to reply than what’s essentially the most useful job.” SAFe offers a method to resolve dependencies between groups—ordering duties is crucial to this consequence.

An illustration titled,
Scaled Agile’s Weighted Shortest Job First components prioritizes duties by weighing the price of delay towards the problem and period of the work required.

Marouane’s path to dependency decision grew to become unsure: “After two sprints, earlier than the primary examine and adapt, we seen that some groups weren’t following our PI plan.” Dependencies that have been outlined within the PI plan weren’t being adopted, so one workforce’s work couldn’t start as a result of the contribution from one other workforce wasn’t prepared.

“Because it was the primary iteration, and the groups weren’t used to this sort of work, we determined to place an additional ceremony into place—a weekly assembly to debate progress on dependencies,” Marouane says. “One particular person from every workforce got here to replace progress on their contributions.” This manner, if Crew A mentioned they have been unable to ship, Crew B may know forward of time and plan accordingly, as an alternative of ready for contributions that weren’t going to materialize in the beginning of their dash.

Leffingwell preaches warning when making these sorts of changes to SAFe: “SAFe is a system of tasks. … You possibly can adapt it, however you’ve bought to be actually cautious.” Though the framework is meant to be adaptable, adjustments are likely to get baked in if not reassessed. The Important SAFe configuration exists to be sure that any alterations meet primary standards.

Marouane’s additional ceremony was included once more within the second PI, and by the third it had been phased out. Groups had nothing to report on that hadn’t already been communicated. Just a little additional flexibility allowed Marouane to get the groups again onto a extra conventional course of observe. She discovered that the transition itself required an Agile mindset to get essentially the most out of the monetary establishment’s groups. And importantly, the change she made, by means of its dedication to steady enchancment, finally served the Lean-Agile rules which can be the groundwork of Important SAFe. Her resolution gave the corporate the unified imaginative and prescient it lacked and allowed the groups to work collectively towards the identical priorities.

Adapt for the Future

Any framework working at scale goes to come back with challenges. The variety of transferring elements and competing pursuits is immense. However the payoffs are equally massive, and a well-executed transition will give groups the instruments they should work towards frequent targets. The obstacles you face in such a large-scale implementation can be unpredictable, and an Agile mindset helped Villena, Anicin, and Marouane adapt to sudden challenges. In spite of everything, that’s what steady supply is for: empowering your course of with the instruments to adapt to the unexpected.

Scaled Agile additionally adapts to new applied sciences and evolving trade requirements, introducing new instruments and capabilities as mandatory. Everybody wants to remain nimble and put together for the sudden. “We now have no crystal ball,” says Leffingwell. “We simply run quick, lead exhausting, and observe exhausting—and write as quick as we are able to.”



[ad_2]

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments